Cemex lagoon 2

The Cemex sand mine in Marina is suspected as the reason southern Monterey Bay has the highest coastal erosion rate in California.

The sand mine in Marina, which has caused southern Monterey to have the highest coastal erosion rate in the state, and is the only remaining coastal sand mine in the country, has been illegal from the start.

But it's not because it's ravaged the local coastline for more than 50 years, it's because the county never issued it a permit. 

On Jan. 14—the same day the Weekly ran a cover story about the mine—Mike Novo, former director of the Monterey County Resources Management Agency, sent a letter to the California Coastal Commission in response the agency’s inquiry about the property and mining operation.

The mine has been in operation since 1959, and in 1965, the owners of the mine moved the extraction site from an inland pond to a dredge pond on the beach, where it has continued operating ever since.

And according to Novo’s letter, the county has never issued a use permit for the mine, which means it’s been operating illegally for over 50 years.

“According to our records, no use permit was obtained,” Novo writes. “Therefore, when the dredge was created and put into operation in 1965, it lacked the necessary authorization…

“Since a use permit would have been required for this site for use of a dredge-pond, from 1955 on, and one was never obtained, it cannot be considered legal.”

The Coastal Commission shared the letter with the Weekly in response to a Public Records Act request, and it reveals a substantive piece of leverage the agency has in its ongoing negotiations with Cemex—the company that acquired the mine in 2005—which came after the agency threatened to issue a cease and desist order against the operation on March 17, based on several alleged Coastal Act violations.

Cemex has been granted a third extension—until June 23—to respond with its “statement of defense,” and in talking with Coastal Commission staff, further extensions seem likely until negotiations wrap up or are called off.

“It’s our policy, whenever we can, to settle with an alleged violator,” says Alex Helperin, a senior staff counsel for the agency. “It seems like every time we issue an order, unilaterally we get sued, and it’s two years of litigation.”

Helperin says Coastal Commission staff have met with Cemex about a half dozen times in the past months, and that negotiations are intensifying.

When asked if the Coastal Commission might allow the mine to continue operating with less intensive extractions, Helperin says “all options are on the table, we’ve considered everything.”

He adds, however, that whatever agreement the agency reaches, Coastal Commission staff has to believe the law supports it.

John Del Arroz, a statewide enforcement analyst with the agency, adds that the issuance of any order—whether it's a cease and desist order or a mutually agreed upon consent order—is subject to a public hearing.

Del Arroz adds that extensions are not uncommon when negotiations are ongoing.

“We would rather have them engaged in negotiations than honing their defenses,” he says. “Once people start to do that, it encourages them to think in a way that’s adversarial rather than cooperative.”

The other documents obtained by the PRA request are mostly scheduling emails between Coastal Commission staff and Sacramento-based attorney Bonnie Neely, who is representing Cemex, and who served on the Coastal Commission from 1998-2010, acting as chair in her last two years.

Helperin says more recent communications between the agency and Neely are confidential, and would not be released until negotiations wrap up.

Recommended for you

(1) comment

Jason Garcia

Cemex has the highest rate of coastal erosion because it's the only operational mining quary on California's coast to date. I've studied the ecosystem on that site for years. That location supports the most dense population of endangered birds out of any other location on California's coast lines. The wild life are attracted to the mining pond and are carefully protected and fenced off by the Cemex employees. I am a 10 year resident of Marina, moving there to bring my studies close to home, and because of the relaxed environment of the hard working locals. Cemex supplies the small Marina community with very helpful and much needed revenue as well. Sponsoring local sports and providing people all around with from different states with materials that go into building bridges, to protecting underground water/electric/gas lines under each and every persons house. Employees will do a coast clean up of trash such as wood and plastic debris, and ship nets that promote harm to ocean wildlife. I have spoke with employees in the past years when storms hit the central coast. That picture used above is trying to sway people reading this article, that they are dredging in the ocean. When the walls of the permitted pond Cemex dredges from breaks, due to high waves/tide etc, Cemex haults All mining till tide recedes restoring pond separation from ocean. I mining enthusiast by any means but have learned first hand over the years observing and conversing with Cemex employees and their operations. I also fear that if shut down the Marina coast will become more populated promoting harm to endangered birds and plant life that inhabit a nearly untouched, virgin coast. Some will judge a book by it's cover, but the media tends to use drastic statements/pictures to sway uneducated readers into believing all companies are evil. Those Cemex employees too like you, work to support their families. Working on and around the site for the last decade taught me that not all miners carry the crude money hungry traits we are expected to believe...

-Please help protect the life of the beautiful Snowy Pluver by educating yourself on how a healthy habitat/ecosystem is preserved. Thank you for reading.
-J Garcia

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.