Squid Speaks

Into the Shallows…Squid struggles to keep up with the news some weeks, trying to keep count of who’s really in and who’s really out of the Democratic presidential field. Squid hadn’t even finished filling out Squid’s bracket to place bets on who would advance to the general election when candidates started dropping out.

Squid thought it would be much easier to keep up with a local news story, albeit one that has plenty of twists and turns. That story would be the Monterey Peninsula Water Supply Project, California American Water’s answer to a state cease-and-desist order that mandates the bulk of the region’s water supply come from anywhere besides the Carmel River.

Part of that project is a $329 million desalination plant, which would feature intake wells on Marina’s beaches and promises to work some (very high-priced) magic and convert seawater into freshwater. The desal plant has faced opposition every step of the way based on cost, footprint, impacts to ocean ecology, energy consumption and whether said intake wells, which draw seawater into the plant, will negatively affect the groundwater that Marina relies on.

Cal Am has gotten through a few essential steps to making this mega-project a reality, but a number of requirements remain. Among them: securing a coastal development permit from the city of Marina to build the intake wells.

Cal Am anticipated a lot of hostility to this permit, and rightly so, given that the group Citizens for Just Water in Marina has deployed a small army of volunteers to wade through mountains of water-related documents with the mission of showing that the desal plant would harm Marina’s water supply, and violate water rights rules. (Cal Am’s analysis, naturally, shows no harm, no foul.)

The latest stack of documents in this battle is a 431-page agenda packet that was originally slated to go to Marina City Council last week, on April 30. But then Cal Am sent the city a letter hundreds of pages long demanding that three of the five council members recuse themselves because of their alleged bias against the desalination plant. That would’ve left only two council members—not enough for a quorum, not enough for a vote.

Squid was already melting butter for the popcorn Squid was going to snack on during the April 30 meeting, anticipating a heated and vigorous discussion about what constitutes bias. But then, one day before the meeting, Cal Am suddenly withdrew its appeal.

What? Squid was confused—everything Squid knew about Cal Am’s strategy before that date included this hearing. Cal Am knew the Marina Planning Commission would ixnay their permit (check), and that they’d have to then file an appeal to the Marina City Council. They anticipated the “biased” council would also reject the permit, and next they’ll appeal to the California Coastal Commission.

So Squid was confused to see Cal Am suddenly change course. Even though the company withdrew its appeal, Squid oozed on over to Marina City Hall on April 30 anyway. Before the meeting started, local officials were overheard exchanging bewildered speculation about Cal Am’s “chess game” strategy. Was it a blunder or a checkmate?

Meanwhile, public water advocates filed in to the chambers, clutching the remarks they had prepared. But the meeting lasted only several minutes. The council members and the city attorney said they’d been thrown off and needed more time to respond. Was that Cal Am’s game plan all along?

Squid’s not sure, but City Council appears to be proceeding as if nothing happened. The meeting has been rescheduled for today, May 6, with the same 431-page packet.

Squid wonders if you can have a meeting about an appeal that’s been withdrawn. Is that like the sound of one hand clapping? Whether the meeting is a go or not, Squid will be listening hard to hear the sound of Marina pushing back against Cal Am, and Squid expects it to be spirited—much louder than the sound of one hand clapping. 


Need that appliance fixed?  Lawn overgrown? Find all that and more in the Monterey County Weekly  Service Directory, click here.

Time for a haircut? Need a massage? Find all that and more in the Back Cover, click here.

Become a Member Today


It takes a huge effort for Monterey County Weekly to stay independent and deliver the quality news, arts & entertainment you’ve come to depend on. We’re inviting our readers to join our new membership program, a new way to support independent, local media.

Learn more.

Recommended for you

(2) comments

PT Flee

Build the desal in Carmel.

Bingo! No more trouble from Marina!

Jeffrey Weekley

I attended the Planning Commission hearing where CalAm applied for the coastal zone permit for the slant wells. They misrepresented the validity of their water model, claiming it had been blessed by Lawrence Berkeley National Lab, when in fact they said it was deeply flawed. They cherry-picked two of the driest years on record to try to establish that there was significant salt water intrusion into the Marina aquifers, when in fact during normal periods, there is little on-shore flow of salt water.

And no one, not even Cal-Am could answer the question of, “Why Marina?” It was pretty clear to everyone there it was because no one in the more affluent parts of the peninsula would allow such a project on their shoreline. The only proponents of the plan were large, corporate hospitality interests and the public works manager for Castroville, who is a Cal-Am subscriber. That leaves me to ask, then, why not in Castroville?

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.