Total Catch

Real Good Fish affiliate fishermen haul in a member favorite, Dungeness crab, off the coast of Davenport (north of Santa Cruz) while aboard the F/V Gayle.

There’s a certain poetry to what Local Catch Monterey, freshly renamed Real Good Fish, is accomplishing in its mission to connect local seafood lovers with local fishermen via a CSA-style subscription service.

It is working slowly and patiently to cure a system built for people demanding fish quickly and conveniently.

It offers a regional alternative to a national fishery that bizarrely imports 90 percent of the seafood we eat and exports a third of what we catch.

It invests in close connections to food so frequently distanced from its source and the seasons.

It brings a brave approach to perishability with the hope of making change that doesn’t ever go bad.

Its co-founder and mastermind, Alan Lovewell, is a man who understands the way things works – he fixes cars and replaces his own iPhone glass using toothpicks to tighten the tiny screws – and has tasked himself with fixing something incredibly complex that’s been simplified to a painfully incomplete data point: price.

“When we’re buying fish,” he says, “we’re not valuing local jobs, the transportation and lower carbon footprint.”

The program works simply enough: Buy a weekly subscription for $22, which means 1-2 pounds of seafood to feed 2-4 people. It sounds vague, but a Monday email alert allows more precise planning. Pick up the haul at one of the many drop points on Tuesday. Embrace adventure, as it can be anything from anchovies to oysters, and the accompanying education, in the form of fisherman lore and fun recipes. And love the yum: the petrale sole I took home last week was so fresh it barely needed olive oil, garlic, lemon, herbs, an aluminum foil envelope and the oven before we were swimming in clean flavor.

Eaters get great fish; fishermen get a reprieve from the pressures of failing fisheries, marine-protected areas, catch quotas and fickle market forces. Or as now departed co-founder Oren Frey, a National Marine Fisheries Service Sea Grant fellow like Lovewell, put it, “People get a good price [and] fishermen get predictable demand.”

The rebranding and accompanying strategic shifts come with its third anniversary, and are designed to draw more members into that exchange.

The evolving approach includes a new office and a slick new website with FAQs, fishermen profiles, fresh recipes (Moroccan fish tagine! Abalone Meuniere! Baked sea bass!) and a blog that covers everything from the malignance of mislabeling to how to open an oyster.

Other developments both innovative and practical will help lift membership from around 500 to a goal of 1,000, drawing from further points north, something that’s already being realized with the recent addition of two Marin drop spots. Bay to Tray Program takes grenadier, a fish that’s unintended bycatch and typically discarded, and pops it in local public school lunches – instead of oft-imported, farmed fish – in tasty things like fish tacos and enchiladas. Other schools are taking notice. A partnership with Kitchen Witch Bone Broth in Santa Cruz means the RGF bones and heads simmer into delicious and fortifying broth, furnishing another instance of a former waste stream suddenly becoming something wholesome and valuable. New add-on options for subscribers allow for more creative and diverse seafood options like smoked salmon bellies, local squid and even calamari kimchi, and complimentary spices like gomasio from Lightly Salted and sauce-friendly canned produce from Happy Girl Kitchen.

A growing staff, starring new hire Maria Finn, enhances marketing and member services while pulling in more members from the other bay area (San Francisco), and creating more pickup spots here. Another delivery vehicle, or “Fishmobile,” helps there too.

Relationships with suppliers like Del Mar Seafoods in Watsonville and Sea Harvest in Moss Landing, which occupies the space above the new HQ, are deepening to maximize efficiencies.

“There’s a lot of support and capacity in the community,” Lovewell says. “So much of our seafood is going to Asia, or the East Coast. A lot goes to restaurants as well, but eaters don’t know where it came from or who caught it. That’s where we come in. The opportunity we see now that we’ve created this market is to develop the market.”

The third birthday party happens 3-6pm Sunday, March 8, at the new headquarters at 7532 Sandholdt Road, Moss Landing, with its own poetic swarm. The gifted Good Sams bring the live music. Hook Fish Company cooks up the fish tacos. (All food and drink is subsidized, but not free; bring cash.) RGF orchestrates DIY sushi while Kitchen Witch brews fish bone broth. Bonny Doon pours wine. Santa Cruz Mountain Brewery flows beer. Anyone who wants to can tour RGF stalwart fishing boat the F/V Pioneer. All are encouraged to bring surfboards, wetsuits and seafood lovers, and to RSVP at

Lovewell will be there after time in Astoria, Oregon, for the FisherPoets Gathering where the main two ingredients are fishermen and, yes, poetry. He dropped some on me unintentionally before he left. “Getting rich quick is building apps of little or no value in 2-3 years,” he said. “Building and changing a community takes years and years, investment and investment, a lot of patience, a lot of energy, a lot of heart.”


• Perfectly Pressed 3 and its wowser juices are coming to… Prunedale. Hit the blog for more.

• Casanova (625-0501) has launched a two-course lunch deal that includes a half glass of wine (3 ounces) for $20.With food like this week’s roasted pumpkin-pesto salad followed by schnitzel, potatoes and braised cabbage, that’s a solid deal in a storybook setting. But it’s the carefully curated wines designed to feature new terroirs from a cellar team currently vying for a James Beard award that is the real kicker.

• The Community Palette art show/business plan contest/creative explosion a year ago made for one of the most inspiring nights of the year, food included. Now #2 is here. See p. 30.

• The fourth Annual Watsonville Film Festival arrives March 5-8, with lots of food content. Look for a blog post soon.

• Mal’s Market (394-1881), home of the bomber and a killer Philly cheesesteak (ask for the jalapeño spread), now has a humble patio for sunny afternoons in Seaside. Or mornings, as their breakfast sandwich is as good as any.

• The Choke Coach (214-2587) by Pezzini Farms in Castroville has an artichoke po’ boy. They also do parties.

• Plant Seeds of Love fundraiser lets green thumbs purchase pots and start an organic herb and veggie garden 3-9pm Sunday, March 8, at Carmel’s San Carlos Square. Hors d’oeuvres and drinks are served.

• Every Wednesday in March, Buffalo Wild Wings donates 10 percent of sales to the Boys and Girls Club of Monterey County when diners present a printed ticket (download at

• Marina Chamber of Commerce holds a free mixer 5:30-7:30pm Thursday, March 5, at Cheesecake Dreamations, which offers divine little bites.

• Sweet Thing still makes the Juice Plus+ push: Dr. David Phillips speaks on the health benefits of Plus+ 7pm Friday, March 6 at Bayonet and Black Horse Golf Course (contact 277-2684).

• Leonard Nimoy, who passed away Feb. 27 at age 83, and was stationed at Fort Ord in the ’50s, beam us out: “The miracle is this,” he once said. “The more we share the more we have.

Recommended for you

(0) comments

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.